Cornoring Stores

Eden Tesfay owned a store on the corner of Summit and Sixth street in Weinland Park for years. That store is now rubble.

Natalia's Carry Out, formerly located at the corner of Summit St. and E. 6th Ave., was shut down in 2017 after the City of Columbus declared the property a public nuisance.
Two years after it was shut down, Natalia's Carry Out was demolished. The site remains empty and under the ownership of Eden Tesfay.


Natalia’s Carry Out was, as you may have guessed, a carryout in the Columbus, Ohio, neighborhood of Weinland Park. The business was located across the street from a community park, an elementary school, and an early childhood center. The store was shut down in 2017, when the City of Columbus declared it a nuisance. 

That year, the City of Columbus filed a complaint against Natalia’s Carry Out for having “a general reputation in the community and among the Columbus Police as a public nuisance.” It, according to the complaint, was known to be a location where “gang members, felons, and persons with active warrants hang out.” From 2015 to 2017, “police responded to Natalia’s Carry Out on reports of shootings, assaults, disturbances, weapons offenses, and drug activity.” Additionally, the store’s manager sold alcohol to an undercover underage informant for Columbus Police on six separate occasions, and police sent the property owner multiple notifications and warnings about the operations at Natalia’s.

In the end, the Franklin County Municipal Environmental Court order the store to shut down, and the building was demolished in 2018.

Natalia’s Carry Out seems, at first glance, to be a straightforward case; clearly the business broke laws and didn’t take adequate steps to address its problems. But here, context matters. Weinland Park borders The Ohio State University, and it’s a neighborhood that the City and Campus Partners, a collaboration between the university and developers, have focused on transforming. 

In the past, other cities such as Cincinnati have pursued neighborhood development — or dare we say gentrification? — in part by buying up or closing down locally-owned carry outs. Columbus, Ohio is going through it’s own period of expansion, with less expensive areas becoming hotspots for growth. This economic, demographic and cultural change is why we’re also investigating the cornerstore’s intersection with crime. Many of the same charges leveled against Natalia’s Carry Out — weed, underage alcohol sales — could be leveled against higher-end bars in the Short North, but often aren’t. We want to explore how Natalia’s Carry Out fits into these broader efforts to “rebuild” Weinland Park.

Through this podcast, we want to explore whether law enforcement is fairly applied to all areas of Columbus, how wealthier stakeholders are trying to shape the area, and whether the vision and strategy of Weinland Park development will actually produce an equitable, just, and socio-economically diverse neighborhood.

Weinland Park is located in Columbus between Ohio State’s campus and downtown. It’s found between North High Street and Milo Grogan, between 11th and 5th avenues. 

Matter is a digital news source for all of us who receive too much information and not enough context. We are investigative, community-informed, multimedia, nonprofit and local.

We investigate the most pressing issues in Columbus in the format that can best tell the story, including videos, articles, podcasts, games and more. Our multimedia content is tailored story by story to ensure comprehension, engagement, accessibility and empowerment for the Columbus community and beyond. We investigate one issue at a time, using a “deep dive” model (once we grow, we will cover a few issues at a time). This targeted approach allows our reporters and editor to dig deeper, to explain more of the nuance and context and to cultivate a more profound understanding of what they’re covering. We are also one of the only locally-owned, nonprofit news outlets in Columbus, meaning we are not funded by advertisers with a profit motive. Most importantly, our content is free and we aim to be as accessible as possible.

Our Natalia’s Carry Out podcast is headed by the intrepid Ris Twigg, Matter News’ managing editor. She’s an Ohio State graduate with a background in environmental and urban development. The team also includes reporters and producers Taijuan Moorman and Olivia Miltner, who both have experience reporting and writing about Columbus. Our editor-in-chief, Jaelynn Grisso, is a jack-of-all-trades and provides wisdom, web development and fundraising support. 

We will have eight to 10 episodes that each run 20 to 30 minutes.

Once the podcast is completed, weekly shows will be broadcast on a local NPR affiliate, WCBE, and episodes will be available on popular streaming platforms such as Google Podcasts, Apple Podcasts, Stitcher and Spotify.

Your donation is essential for supporting every aspect of our podcast. We’ve already laid the groundwork by researching and contacting sources to make sure our idea is viable and can become a reality. Now we need funding to pay for equipment and studio time, along with — most importantly — paying our wonderful and dedicated team. 

Right now, our most pressing need is money. We have the time, we have the talent, but we need the treasure. If you’re interested in further financially supporting Matter News and the investigative local journalism we produce, please become a member by signing up to give monthly donations. You set the rate — we appreciate every little bit.

Additionally, help us get the word out about Natalia’s Carry Out and Matter News! Follow us on Twitter and Instagram, drop us a like on Facebook and share our content.

We also host a variety of get-togethers around Columbus and often have a booth at community events, so keep an eye out for the next time we’re near you; we’d love for you to stop by!

We also send a monthly newsletter with our content and updates, which you can sign up for here.

Have an idea for a story? A pressing issue you wish local media would talk about? Simply a question about local development you’d like unpacked? We’re here you, just send us a message at

We are currently unable to pay for contributions, although we’re hoping to change that through fundraising for projects like this podcast. If you’re a reporter or writer interested in working with us, we’d be happy to meet with you to discuss volunteer opportunities. Otherwise, we’d love to reconnect when we can pay you for your wonderful work. 

Matter News